In its 3/25/10 Opinion, the Ninth Circuit yesterday reversed Judge Karlton's order, which enjoined California Proposition 9's parole revocation procedures because of a conflict with a permanent injunction agreed to by California in resolving a class action lawsuit. The Appellate Court remanded to Judge Karlton to make further findings. Judge Noonan filed a partial dissent to the majority opinion by Judges Michael Hawkins and Milan Smith.